A brand new Scotland: the controversy will train the hearts and minds of voters in that nation till subsequent month’s referendum.
It was additionally a query confronted by a technology of Scots 250 years in the past.
However they needed to sail throughout the Atlantic to search out their Nova Scotia.

Disappearing act: Sian Lloyd raises a glass to the fun and freedom of journey in Nova Scotia
Because the independence arguments raged – and as my husband and I yearned for traffic-free roads, bushes and foodie treats – we booked a last-minute Icelandair flight to Halifax, Nova Scotia’s capital, and for every week toured components of this remoted jap peninsula of Canada.
Over two-thirds of the province is roofed by forest – conifers, after all, however maple, birch, oak and mountain ash too. Nova Scotia can be the world’s largest exporter of blueberries and Christmas bushes.
Celtic music could be very a lot alive right here and is likely one of the highlights of a go to; one other is the freshly cooked lobster; one more the whalewatching. Briefly, there’s quite a bit on provide.
There is definitely a variety of family tree to find. Inside 5 minutes of our arrival, the jolly doorman at The Lord Nelson Resort in Halifax proudly instructed us that he was 1 / 4 French and 1 / 4 Scottish.
He waxed lyrical about how 1000’s of Highlanders came to visit and combined in with French, English and Germans to type the distinctive pressure of folks often known as Nova Scotians.

A haven within the New World: Nova Scotia’s capital Halifax boasts a stunning waterside setting
The foremost Scottish inflow to Nova Scotia started in 1773, when the Hector sailed into Pictou – acknowledged because the birthplace of New Scotland. It is a simple drive there from Halifax.
A powerful full-size reproduction of the Hector was constructed within the city and is now within the harbour. Most of the guides are descendants of households that came to visit on the Hector.
But it surely’s exhausting to consider such a small vessel made it throughout the Atlantic.
A walkabout under deck will get you questioning on the bravery and tenacity of these 200 early settlers. You may nearly hear the melancholic notes of the pipes as you emerge blinking into the daylight.
From Pictou we took a two-hour scenic drive to the luxurious golf-focused resort of Fox Harb’r on the Northumberland Strait, passing small marshy tidal inlets and mild rolling farmland on the best way.
You do not have to be obsessive about golf to remain right here, however the beautiful coastal panorama and the manicured course are sufficient to make you actually wish to study.
We selected to cycle and swim within the spectacular 25-metre pool.


Splendid sights: Sian encountered the Uisge Ban waterfalls (left), and the Crimson Shoe Pub in Inverness (proper)
We additionally went on fantastic walks on the beachfront and within the forests of the Cobequid Mountains, found the stunning native Jost wines, and slept like infants on down pillows in gigantic beds.
Unsurprisingly for a province referred to as New Scotland, there are a good few high golf programs. We drove for half a day to get to Inverness in western Cape Breton, so as to keep on the superbly stylish glass-fronted Cabot Hyperlinks golf course, and to faucet our toes to Celtic reels on the well-known Crimson Shoe Pub.
Cabot Hyperlinks hugs the shore, and is recognised as one of many world’s best golf programs. The splendour of the place is really appreciated from the Panorama restaurant.
We witnessed two chic sunsets and loved two numerous lobster-stuffed ravioli and blueberry cobblers. Scenic, serene and delicious.
We have been very eager to cycle a part of the Celtic Shores Path. This 60-mile well-kept coastal observe stretches from Publish Hastings to Inverness, and has been on my bucket record for a while.
It’s accessed simply down the street from Cabot Hyperlinks, and is a pure pleasure to cycle.
We went so far as Mabou and again, breaking the journey with a late lunch on the Crimson Shoe, which is owned by the folk-singing Rankin sisters.
Each meals and musicianship are second to none.

Doughty: The harbour at Pictou has a duplicate of the Hector, which introduced Scottish immigrants to Nova Scotia
We tucked in to crab dips with flatbreads and mussels and candy potato chips, having fun with the heady mixture of meals, enjoyable and fiddling, and staying far longer than we anticipated.
We loved sunny gin-clear skies whereas on Cape Breton, so saved the indoor sights until final, simply in case the climate misbehaved. It did not, so we somewhat rushed round must-visit sights just like the Alexander Graham Bell Museum and the Gaelic School, the place we helped weave a kilt.
Each locations have been entertaining and pleasing and left us questioning whether or not we should always have spent fairly a lot time on the splendid Uisge Ban Falls; or chatting with lobster fishers at Baddeck’s pretty village market; or loitering over breakfast with proprietor Earlene Busch on the Chanterelle Inn.
This place is a Cape Breton gem, intimate and tranquil, and serving native merchandise, akin to fiddlehead fern soup and native cranberries and blueberries.
The menu adjustments nightly and names all of the meals sources.
Our line-caught halibut was from Neil’s Harbour, about 50 miles away. The bread at breakfast was recent from the oven. Even the oatcakes have been home-made. We left with a beneficiant pile and munched away merrily on our journey to Sherbrooke on the Jap Shore.

As we all know her greatest: Till not too long ago, Sian had labored for ITV since 1990
Sherbrooke village is an enthralling residing museum. It is an precise village, although, fantastically restored to its nineteenth century look and staffed by folks in costume, portraying the experiences of the time.
I rode a penny-farthing, obtained a recipe card from the printing press, watched wild rose hand-cream being made on the pharmacy, visited the phone trade, ate fresh-baked biscuits within the jailer’s kitchen and spun some wool on the weaver’s dwelling.
Disneyland, eat your coronary heart out.
That is the true deal, and that is the factor about Nova Scotia: it’s heat, accessible and genuine. Scratch nearly anybody and you will find a Scot or two within the household tree, a kilt or a fiddle within the closet.
It is as if a piece of auld Scotland has been damaged off by historic giants and hurled on to Canada’s north-east coast. The land and soil look the identical, the climate’s the identical and you discover the identical hardy folks.
In some methods, it’s extra historically Scottish than Scotland.
If Alex Salmond loses the referendum, to ease his sorrows I might completely suggest a visit to Cape Breton, a dance alongside the Ceilidh Path… and loads of the island’s personal single-malt whiskies.